Salve Regina: Newly discovered pieces by Monteverdi and Frescobaldi
reviewed by Michael Schell

Salve Regina: Newly discovered pieces by Monteverdi and Frescobaldi
Il Pegaso, Maurizio Croci
Brilliant Classics, released 2012
Spotify •

An appealing juxtaposition of Frescobaldi and Monteverdi

This selection comes to us from the Italian organist Maurizio Croci and his recently formed Il Pegaso, an impressively international group of musicians based in Fribourg and specializing in early Italian Baroque music (the name is Italian for Pegasus). Recorded in what appears to be a chilly Swiss basilica (the production photos show the performers wearing thick sweaters), the album purports to feature "newly discovered pieces by Monteverdi and Frescobaldi", but this is a bit deceptive. The works in Tracks 1, 3 and 19 have been known for a while, but were only attributed to Monteverdi in 2011. As for Frescobaldi, what's presented in Tracks 4, 12, 13, 16 and 18 are early versions, possibly sketches, of established instrumental pieces, taken from a notebook recently discovered at the Bibliothèque nationale de France. The album is filled out by several other, long-established pieces by the two composers, capped off by an anonymous Romanesca and an attractive theorbo piece by one Bellerofonte Castaldi.

Notwithstanding the "newly discovered" moniker, the real concept of this album is the alternation between Monteverdi Salve Regina settings and Frescobaldi instrumental works. It's an intriguing juxtaposition of works by these two most famous Italian composers of the early 1600s.

The career of Monteverdi (1567–1643) needs little introduction, but I'll note that like all his famous predecessors, he's predominantly known for vocal music. By contrast, Frescobaldi (1583–1643) was the first composer of his stature to base his reputation on instrumental music. He succeeded Claudio Merulo as organist at St. Peter's in Rome, and when he produced his Primo Libro di Toccate e Partite in 1615, it was the first published example of keyboard music written in two staves. Brief examples of several typical Frescobaldi keyboard genres are included here: toccatas (which Frescobaldi inherited from Marulo and developed into a freeform model used by Buxtehude and Bach), partitas (variations over a ground bass, originating in improvisational praxis), ricercars (an early form of fugue) and Italian dance forms such as the corrente (like the French courante) and balletto (like the French allemande). These are generally paired, like a prelude, with a Monteverdi setting of a sacred text, written in his "new way" (seconda prattica) using theme-and-accompaniment textures, phrases organized into functional chord progressions supported by a figured bass, and abrupt changes of tempo and meter—all the stylistic accoutrements that distinguish Baroque music from what preceded it. With their tuneful crooning, these songs are musically indistinguishable from Monteverdi's late madrigals and Venetian operas. Only their Latin texts betray their ecclesiastical intention. The opening of the solo tenor Salve Regina setting in Track 11 is a good example:

The Frescobaldi compositions are more bound to the past, displaying the elegant late Renaissance instrumental counterpoint where each line is given roughly equal weight, and entrances are sequential and imitative. The Second Ricercar (Track 14) is typical. Note the second, inverted, entry of the subject. Played on an organ, with its traditional religious associations, it sounds sacred, and indeed Frescobaldi's ricercars (and toccatas, canzonas and versets) were written to be played at specific points during a church service.

The collection is exquisitely recorded and performed. For example the descending chromatic scale (the so-called "hard way down" or passus duriusculus) on "moaning and weeping in this valley of tears" in the aforementioned Salve Regina (Track 11 at 2:35) is sung with scarcely any vibrato, proving that a classically-trained singer can display good intonation without relying on continuous vibrato:

Il Pegaso uses a theorbo (sometimes with organ added) as the continuo instrument on the vocal tracks, reflecting the current emphasis on lute-type instruments for this role (a welcome contrast to the stereotypical harpsichord inevitably used in older recordings of this music). One disappointment is the liner notes, which do not include texts and which say little about the compositions themselves. Another quibble might be the somewhat narrow timbral range of the ensemble: three male voices, organ and theorbo. But the Frescobaldi + Monteverdi pairing is well-conceived, making this inexpensive album a worthwhile and unique addition to the library of anyone interested in early Baroque music.

- First published November 2015

Selected writings | Schellsburg home
Jerry Hunt | cribbage

Original Material and HTML Coding Copyright © 201518 by Michael Schell. All Rights Reserved.